deanhet • Blog

Art is dead, long live art

25 years ago I sat in a school classroom, in absolute awe of what I now know to be a Valiant Roamer. Look at this little guy:

valiant-roamer

You press the buttons on the back in whatever sequence you like, press go and away the little robot goes to carry out your directions. It was love at first sight. It’s really a core memory of mine as my preadolescent brain was enthralled at the idea of commanding this little robot to march across the table. I didn’t really care where the robot went, it was just the fact that I was making something happen. I could put in anything I wanted and something external to my actions would go into motion. It felt like magic.

The robot was the hook, but the sinker was that we were also introduced to an on-screen, virtual version of the same thing. A turtle we could control on the computer and better yet, instead of tapping forward ten times, you could just write FORWARD 10 instead. It would leave a trail behind it so you could draw. I immediatly started trying to figure out how to draw a spiral. I wasn’t entirely aware of it at the time but I became a programmer that day.

I spent so many of my teenage years hacking. I lived on forums about jailbreaking the PSP (then iPhone, then PS3 etc), big shout-out to Dark_AleX. I wrote a Visual Basic program to mimic a Windows login, faking a blue screen crash on submission but saving the user input to be read for later. There was a community behind this. People all doing the same thing I was and being excited about it.

It was never about running things on hardware that weren’t otherwise allowed. It was never about gathering other people’s passwords. The joy was in just doing the thing. I was just playing. To this day, I spend a lot of my time just tinkering (hello, 3D printer). Much like the robot, it’s less about getting to the end of the table and more about being able to express a way to get there. I’m putting thought into the process and getting real tangible output from it.

I naturally fell into a career. Having inhaled every computer related subject I could get my hands on at school, it just felt right to go to University to study Computer Science. From there it was straight into 12+ years of jobs primarily in consumer-facing apps. Again, I’m just drawing on a screen but now I’m getting paid for it. I get to solve little logic puzzles all day, my creative input drives an end result and as a bonus, other people get to use and see it too. What a dream.

DUH DUH DUH, bad guy music. Enter the advent of ‘AI’ and large language models. It was a slow descent before I realised I was at the bottom of the pit. You can ask anyone that knows me, I’ve made it very clear I am not a fan of AI. I’ve seen people I’m close to gradually lose the ability to think for themselves. Everything becomes very insular as we stop having conversations between ourselves and instead with a third-party. Artistic expression atrophies and human connection stops. I just think there’s so much to learn in the space between succesful ideas. I don’t want to one-shot an amazing app. I want to trip up along the way and better myself and the end product in the process.

That’s all abstracted and hidden away with the sole remit being to please and agree. It’s an addictive unregulated drug that should be treated nothing short of dangerous. Your first hit is free or cheap and sooner rather than later, the dealers are going to start wanting a profit. I get that this reads as hyperbole but you never read about AI making people happier. They now just have the ability to push more things around at a faster pace. There’s a much larger issue here than “it’s taking our jobs”. I truly believe there’s a false economy at play here.

I’m forever a sceptic, but I’d be a fool to think what I write can now best the stolen knowledge of the internet. When I try and properly lean into AI though, I can feel I’m losing a part of my brain and of who I am. I get to the end of the day with a high output. I’ve not really done any of it and yet I’m still somehow exhausted from watching something else do it for me. All of the work with none of the gratification. I speak to people who are just parroting back what Claude told them. We’re offloading everything that made us who we are and then paying in tokens to access it again.

I’ve worked in more than enough environments now to see that this is acceptable. People are happy with it, people embrace it. Job specs where your responsibilities are nothing but babysitting and watching agents scroll by your screen all day. I rejected all of it. I didn’t want to be a part of it. My joy was stolen in the process of automating all the work away.


Something interesting started to happen. The PS5 was hacked and opened up to running anything the user wanted, people started making custom interfaces and removing bloat from their ‘smart’ TV, there are now a whole variety of user-made firmwares for my OP1. Breathing a new lease of life into a piece of hardware that was released 15 years ago. It’s no secret that AI is being used to make all this happen. I find myself refreshing forums again, I’m getting excited about the momentum and progress. There are scenes of builders that are making use of knowledge they wouldn’t otherwise have. There’s a community again. They’re playing and I’m engaged. I’m using these tools and making use of the output.

So here we are, with the stunning realisation that with myself included, absolutely nobody cares about how the robot gets to the end of the table, they just want it there. RIP to the craftmanship of the software industry that once was, to the little boy who just wanted to explore.

There is a healthy dose of downers in this post. I really do think the genie is out of the bottle on this one. The extinction event is on the horizon. We’re flooding ourselves with code reviews from automated agents to only now come to the conclusion that we don’t need reviews at all. Every day is another piece of the process taken out of our hands. My role is largely just passing pieces of text from one prompt to another.

Why should I pay for and use your photoshop when I can just spin up my own? I can reverse engineer anything. Fight slop with slop. I don’t need you, I just need to burn tokens. Your next big funding round is based on an incredibly shallow moat.

Where do we go now?

Despite all of the above, I still believe that no matter how much it might pretend to, AI never can and never will be able to impart wisdom. It can’t mentor people. It can’t build teams, or compromise across stakeholders. It’s never going to change your mind in any meaningful way. It’s atrocious to use for hiring. As much as some parts of the industry try; it can’t make music, it can’t paint, it can’t write, it can’t engage you and make you feel like a person can. People very much are the unique thing about any team/business/product/process and that should be embraced as the competitive advantage that it is.

I think I’ve had my blinders on while the going was good. I just happened to luck into my muse by being in the right place at the right time but now I need to actively find it.

I’m still searching for the turtle, it’s still there somewhere. Maybe just less in my own instructions and more in my connection with others trying to find their way.

#ai#art#community#engineering#software